I am sure others have made witch hats like this, but I didn't look to see how to make one. I just came up with it with the supplies I had at home. I used a paper plate, construction paper, and a cup and then craft decorations for the girls to decorate these with. It was so easy and so cheap because I already had all of the stuff! I do need to find a better way to help keep the hats on the girls. So if you have a better way, go for it!
Here are their hats:
Audrey and my niece Hazel.